TRANS SPIRIT FLOURISHING
  • Home
  • About
    • about this site
    • about the author
    • about transgender
  • Blog
  • Theology
    • Genesis and Creation
    • Freedom and Order
    • Gnosticism and heresy
    • Healing and Hope
    • Resurrection and the Body
    • sharing in New Creation
  • Scriptures
    • Christian love & identity
    • gender variant people in scripture
    • crossdressing
    • marriage and family
    • suffering and transformation
    • all one in Christ Jesus
  • Spirituality
    • Kaleidoscope people
    • trans experiences and reflections
    • spiritual practices
    • seeking justice and shalom
    • trans history
    • pioneer priests & inspirations
  • Resources
    • Trans Awareness Days
    • Celebrating Gender Diversity
    • Australian Trans Christian Stories
    • information & support
    • affirming religious groups
    • prayers & worship
    • trans affirmation in many faiths
    • online video clips
    • further reading
  • Contact

A Sickly Caged Compassion: the Transgender Ideology of Sydney Anglican Diocese

10/22/2018

0 Comments

 
Picture
There is much more than property at stake in current Sydney Anglican developments,  For ultimately, suppression and distortion of the mind and soul is so much more destructive than that of the body.  This is a transgender truth which continues to be violated in so much conservative and fundamentalist Christianity.    Much response has thus, rightly, been made to legal, property based, moves by the Anglican Diocese of Sydney to repress religious freedom within its ranks.  This includes suppression of what its leadership has termed, but not defined, as 'transgender ideology'.  Yet, in its 'Gender Diversity Initial Principles of Engagement' it brings forward its own transgender ideology this week.  This, and the guidelines it proposes (outlined on pages 68-73 of its Standing Committee's Annual Report), represent a powerful, but not to some immediately obvious, attack upon gender diverse people, their families and friends.  For whilst it is laced with language about compassion, it is a typical master of misdirection, based on outdated understandings and a priori convictions about gender diversity and its relationship to human, not least spiritual, growth.  It displays little or no meaningful engagement with the expertise of those engaged in enabling gender diverse people to flourish, never mind the lived experience of transgender people as a whole (even the increasingly visible and articulate gender diverse Anglicans and Christians) themselves.  It reflects a form of misapplied compassion; caged in narrow, false and  controlling  'biblical' preconceptions; seemingly wholly ignoring the realities and insights of intersex and non-binary people in particular; and essentially treating gender diverse people as sick, broken and disabled from knowledge or agency of their own health and freedom.  Such views are not those of the Sydney Anglican diocese alone but widespread in certain types of vocal Christianity and in broader society.  Codified as they are in the Sydney diocese's work however, they offer a disturbing model of practice which will not only harm the lives of gender diverse people within the diocese's own reach but, if taken up elsewhere, will have negative effect more widely.  As a potential vehicle of spiritual abuse, it thus demands critique, opposition, and transformation into something wholesome.

Misdirected Compassion

It would of course be deeply unfair to regard Sydney Diocese's Gender Diversity developments as devoid of compassion.  Undoubtedly those involved in this work include deeply caring Christians who are genuinely struggling with the issues involved, not least some gender diverse people and their families themselves, as well as 'ordinary' Anglicans 'in the pew'.  It is understandable that they should also bring their own theological and biblical understandings to this issue, as relating all things to the love of God among us is a core element in Christian ethics on this and other questions,  There are also no fixed guidelines or pathways which can be applied to all gender diverse people in all circumstances - something which of course also gives the lie to the very idea of an alternative 'transgender ideology' which the Sydney diocese appears to want to promote (for, as I know to my own cost,  arguments within the transgender community itself can be quite lively even though key basics are commonly agreed).  Like sincerity and good will however, merely having feelings of compassion, and even will and energy for it, is not enough.   Compassion is incomplete without a willingness to listen properly to others, especially those most closely involved; without a humility about what wisdom our inherited traditions can offer; and without genuine partnership with expertise in the field. 

Drowning in Ideology

Sydney diocese's Gender Diversity guidelines are thus full of a number of expressions of, and invocations to, 'love, support and care'.  They are also not empty of some good suggestions, Congregations for instance are encouraged 'to be concerned for the whole person not just their gender issues', 'to respect the person and their family', 'not to stare, exclude or isolate gender nonconforming people', 'not to make jokes about gender nonconforming people' or make them into 'a celebrity or spectacle', and 'to be aware that taking or displaying photos' may cause distress.'  Yet such helpful signs of empathy are drowned in an ideological framework which excludes so much other vital understanding and practice.   For it is based on an outdated medical model (or 'Disability'  framework) of gender diversity as sickness and a distorted theological model (or false 'Integrity' framework)  of caged binary gender.  Combined together they make for an offensive ideology in which it is wrongly and crassly asserted that: 'In the beginning, God made humanity male and female, and, in his creative purposes, biological (bodily) sex determines gender' and 'the binary distinctions of male and female are to be embraced and upheld in the lives of Christian men and women.'   The consequences matter.  For well-meaning compassion then becomes not only misdirected and (perhaps unconsciously) mendacious, but, in its effects it is destructive to the minds, souls and lives of vulnerable gender diverse children, adults and their loved ones.

Beyond the Disability framework - Gender Diverse people flourish

The Disability framework to gender diversity is one from which others too are slowly emerging.  There are, for example, still remnants, in law and practice, of the  'gatekeeper' approach to transgender treatment, so much resented by transgender people.  Many well-meaning people, like many less well-informed Sydney Anglicans, understandably thus still struggle to move beyond pity and as sense of responsibility for people they regard essentially as only unfortunate and suffering souls.  Sadly some medical and psychological practitioners are still not immune to this dis-eased approach.  However most mainstream practice and policy in gender diversity care has long since moved on.  Gender diverse person-centred care, based on a participative and informed 'Diversity' or 'Affirming' framework, is now the rightly accepted best pathway to growth.  It is highly significant therefore that the Sydney Anglican diocese makes no mention of the authoritative Standards of Care of WPATH (the World Professional Association of Transgender Health) or Australian bodies (such as ANZPATH).  It also ignores the increasing research of recent decades which shows that gender diverse people flourish so much better when they are viewed as part of the extraordinary diversity of humanity (and, for religious people, of divine creativity itself), rather than as an aberration.  Above all, such developments have also been prompted by the growing movement of gender diverse people who have pride in who we are: not as sick victims or suffering subjects of others' compassion but as agents who can shape our own healing and flourishing, and as people with immense life, insights and gifts which our troubled world desperately needs to receive.  Counseling family and friends, as the Sydney diocese does,  'if appropriate, to provide information about alternative treatments  to those which promote transitioning' is but one example of its unwarranted and potentially damaging resistance to truly life-giving compassion which gender diverse people are finding in other ways.  In contrast, there is a striking lack of any mention of measures to affirm and celebrate gender diverse people on any page of the Sydney diocesan guidelines: no thought of liturgical and other provision for key moments of transition and affirmation; no links to or encouragement to listen, talk and work with others in the transgender world (Christian and secular) who are wrestling so deeply with these issues and who know how beautiful and creative gender diverse people are when they affirm themselves and are affirmed by others. .

Caged by theological pre-judgements

For at the heart of the Sydney Anglican diocese's difficulties in coming to terms with gender diversity is the ecclesiastical trap into which it continues to enclose itself.  The bars of its imprisonment are formed by the now perennial obsessions of its leading figures with narrow and depressing conceptions of humanity and God.  These pre-judgements are superimposed on a limited range of contested Biblical texts which are then given determinative authority over everything, irrespective of the human and divine wisdom to be found in science, reason, lived human experience, and the much much wider liberating and enlarging themes of the Bible as interpreted by others.  As such, it is a theological, as well as medico-disability, transgender ideology which Sydney diocese is promoting and in which it is held in terrible thrall.  Space precludes a full theological critique, but it includes: the extraordinary weight placed on isolated texts such as Genesis 1.27, where humanity created as 'male and female' is construed as forming two tightly bound binary boxes instead of being a description of the broad spectrum of diverse gender identity of which 'male' and 'female' are but two poles; the misuse, and ahistorical, use of the ancient concept of 'the Fall' of humanity, which, whilst being blind to the sheer diversity and creativity of evolution, is employed to label some, and not simply gender diverse people, as fundamentally 'broken', sick or 'disordered'; and, above all, the disregard of other major biblical themes and trajectories, including those of liberation, the affirmation of eunuchs and other 'little ones' and people of dfference, the healing acts of Jesus as acts of transformative grace rather than adherence to religious law, and the dynamics of God's Holy Spirit in bringing about a new creation in which (as in Galatians 3.28) old human-made binary distinctions (such as male and female, Jew and Gentile) are transcended.

Christian alternatives

The sadness is that it does not have to be this way, in Sydney or elsewhere..  Across the world, many Christian bodies are now working with gender diverse people and their allies in seeking genuine understanding and life-giving paths forward which will enable all to flourish fully.  For some of us the pace can often appear very slow, even glacial.  Yet it is happening and it is a matter of sorrow and frustration that Sydney Anglican diocese has turned its back on this and the insights, experience and appropriate participation gender diverse Christians like myself have to offer.   As an Anglican, I rejoice that the Church of my birth (the Church of England), so overwhelmingly fully affirmed transgender people at its General Synod in 2017 (see here), seeking provision of pastoral and liturgical affirmations and building on policy support for gender diverse people in ordained as well as lay ministry.  Others in the Anglican Communion, notably the Episcopal Church of the USA, continue to move further forward in dialogue, affirmation, policy and practical support.  In my own diocese of the Anglican Church Southern Queensland (Brisbane), it has also been heartwarming to see the many ways in our schools, and many parishes, are now slowly beginning to engage positively, offering such welcome support and affirmation to many gender diverse people.  Crucially, such developments have also been enhanced when gender diverse people themselves have been allowed into leadership, as increasing numbers of us come out or enter into ministry, and as more and more personal experience, theological and pastoral resources are produced by and with gender diverse Christians ourselves.  This year's publication of Transfaith (co-authored by Anglican priest and trans woman Christina Beardsley) is but one valuable contribution among many (see here for some further resources).  Should the Anglican diocese of Sydney step back to listen, dialogue and allow gender diverse Christians to help lead and contribute, its stirrings of compassion might find space beyond the cage, and healing rather than sickness for itself and others. 
Picture
Some of the members of the Anglican Diocese of Brisbane (Anglican Church Southern Queensland),,
with co-author the Revd Dr Chris Dowd, at the Australian launch of Transfaith in Brisbane earlier this year

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    The Revd Dr Jo Inkpin:
    an Anglican priest, theologian, justice & peace activist, and trans woman in Australia

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    November 2024
    July 2024
    March 2024
    November 2023
    October 2023
    August 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    August 2022
    May 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017

    Categories

    All
    2 Corinthians
    ABBI
    ABC
    Abuse
    Acts
    Advent
    Affirmation
    Affirming
    Agency
    Alex Pittaway
    Amao Leota Lu
    Anglican
    Apology
    Archbishop Of Adelaide
    Art
    Assembly
    Audre Lorde
    Australia
    Authenticity
    Autogynephilia
    Awareness
    Baptism
    Benjamin Oh
    Bernie Taupin
    Bible
    Billy Bragg
    Birth
    Bishop
    Bishop Budde
    Blessing
    Body
    Breath
    Brisbane
    Candle In The Wind
    Carla Robinson
    Cathedral
    Celtic
    Chalise Van Wyngaardt
    Children
    Chris Dowd
    Christ
    Christa
    Christian
    Christian Lives Matter
    Christina Beardsley
    Christmas
    Church
    Commandment
    Covenant
    Covid 19
    Covid-19
    Creation
    Crucifixion
    Dangerous Women
    Discrimination
    Donald Trump
    Dragonfly
    Dress
    Easter
    Eddie Ayres
    Elizabeth 1
    Elton John
    England
    Episcopal Church
    Equality
    Equal Voices
    Eucharist
    Eunuch
    Eve
    Expansive
    Expansiveness
    Experience
    Faith
    Faithfully Me
    Fall
    Female
    Feminism
    Flourishing
    Forgiveness
    Freedom
    Future Church
    Garry Deverell
    Gender
    Gender Centre
    Gender Diversity
    Gender Expansive
    Gerard Manley Hopkins
    Gifts
    God
    Gospel
    Grace
    Guardian Australia
    Harry Potter
    Healing
    Health
    History
    Holly Zwalf
    Hope
    Hymn
    IDAHOBIT
    Inclusion
    Indecency
    Intersectionality
    Isaiah
    Jacob
    Janet Rice
    Jesus
    Jesus Queen Of Heaven
    J.K.Rowling
    J Mase III
    Jo Clifford
    John 3
    Joke
    Josephine
    Joy
    Judith Butler
    Julia Serano
    Kaleidoscope
    Leadership
    LGBTI+
    LGBTIQ
    Liberation
    Life And Death
    Listen
    Liturgy
    London
    Love
    Love Of God
    Marcella Althaus Reid
    Mardi Gras
    Marilyn Munro
    Marriage
    Mary
    Mary Magdalene
    Mary Oliver
    MCC
    Melbourne
    Mercy
    Meredith Lake
    Milton
    Minister
    Muslim
    Name
    Namoli Brenett
    Naomi
    Narcissim
    Neighbour
    New Creation
    Noah Riseman
    Non-binary
    Norrie
    Onlyness
    Ordination
    Pain
    Parents Of Gender Diverse Children
    Paul
    Penny Jones
    Penny Whetton
    Peter Kline
    Peterson Toscano
    PFLAG
    Pitt Street
    PItt Street Uniting Church
    Play
    Pope Francis
    Power
    Prayer
    Presbytery
    Pride
    Priest
    Primate
    Project 42
    Prophetic
    Puberty
    Queensland
    Queer
    Queer Theology
    Rachel Lane
    Racism
    Rainbow
    Rainbow Christians Together
    Raquel Willis
    Reconciliation
    Religious
    Religious Discrimination
    Remembering
    Repentance
    Resistance
    Resources
    Resurrection
    Rhett Pearson
    Ricki Coughlan
    Rite
    Rohan Salmond
    Ruth
    Safe Schools
    Saint
    Salvation Army
    Same Gender
    Same Sex
    Same-sex
    SBS
    Scripture
    Selva Neblina
    Sexuality
    Shame
    Sibyls
    Silence
    Solidarity
    Sorèl
    Sorel Coward
    Sorèl Coward
    Soul
    Spirit
    Spiritual
    Spirituality
    Spiritual Misfits
    State Library
    Steff Fenton
    Story
    Struggle
    Suffering
    Surgery
    Sydney
    Synod
    Tasmania
    TDoV
    Theology
    Theroux
    Toowoomba
    Trans
    Trans Day Of Remembrance
    Trans Day Of Visibility
    TransEpiscopal
    Transformation
    Transgender
    Trans Ing
    Trans-ing
    Transitioning
    Transphobia
    Truth
    Uniting Church
    Uniting Network
    USA
    Vacuum
    Visibility
    Voice
    Vulnerability
    Water
    Will Small
    Women
    World Pride
    Worship
    Wound

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • About
    • about this site
    • about the author
    • about transgender
  • Blog
  • Theology
    • Genesis and Creation
    • Freedom and Order
    • Gnosticism and heresy
    • Healing and Hope
    • Resurrection and the Body
    • sharing in New Creation
  • Scriptures
    • Christian love & identity
    • gender variant people in scripture
    • crossdressing
    • marriage and family
    • suffering and transformation
    • all one in Christ Jesus
  • Spirituality
    • Kaleidoscope people
    • trans experiences and reflections
    • spiritual practices
    • seeking justice and shalom
    • trans history
    • pioneer priests & inspirations
  • Resources
    • Trans Awareness Days
    • Celebrating Gender Diversity
    • Australian Trans Christian Stories
    • information & support
    • affirming religious groups
    • prayers & worship
    • trans affirmation in many faiths
    • online video clips
    • further reading
  • Contact